RATINGS | Aston Villa 5-0 Liverpool: How close are young Reds to first-team picture?

Player ratings, with a twist — in a unique situation, Don Kopleone rates the players not on their performances in the Carabao Cup quarter-final, but on what they mean for their respective chances of breaking into the first team any time soon.

No comments

With an average age of less than 20 amongst the starting line-up, this was never going to be a normal game for the Reds. All that mattered was the youngsters played with passion and pride — the ‘Liverpool way’.

And that they did. A positive start was marked with a good chance for Herbie Kane, but he was denied by Aston Villa’s reserve ‘keeper Ørjan Nyland.

Shortly after that, however, a few fortunate goals for the home side saw Liverpool’s makeshift side go three goals down, albeit against the run of play.

The young Reds — inspired by Harvey Elliott — continued to create chances, but a badly-defended fourth before half-time killed off the tie as a contest.

Like what you see? Get it for free!

Get all of our content delivered straight to your inbox — completely free of charge.

The second-half was a tighter affair, but after striker Wesley entered the game as a substitute he was able to slot home a fifth.

Anyway, as this team and game was so unique, I’m using an adapted ratings system tonight:

1 — Currently a very long way off the level required for the first team
2 — Not yet near first-team standard
3 — Could push for a first-team opportunity in the coming years
4 — Could offer a rotation option for the first team
5 — Will make first-team appearances sooner rather than later

Here we go, then:

Starting XI

Kelleher 1 — Arguably let himself down for three of the five goals. A long way to go, despite his penalty heroics last time out.

Hoever 4 — Already has the top level athleticism required.

Van den Berg 2 — Does not look quite the prospect we thought we were picking up in the summer. Slow on the turn and some sketchy positioning.


Boyes 1 — Unlucky with the own goal, but the kid looked out of his depth.

Gallacher 3 — Considering our lack of left-back depth, the Scot could conceivably fill-in in the first team, at some point. Good effort from distance late-on.

Christie-Davies 3 — Composed on the ball and full-blooded in the challenge. Impressive.

Chirivella 2 — While you could sense the Spaniard’s greater experience, a few misplaced passes could have caused problems on the counter-attack.

Kane 2 — Unlucky not to score on multiple occasions. Could see him getting a chance if he were 19, but at 21, Kane was one of the Reds’ oldest players today.

Elliott 5 — Would cause problems in the Premier League right now. Looked the best player on the pitch at times and is still only 16 years old. Special.

Longstaff 1 — Did precious little and seemed to press inefficiently, although we are used to a freak in Roberto Firmino.

Hill 2 — Couple of bursts of pace from the 17-year-old, but lacks physicality.


Bearne 1 — Hardly impacted the game.

Clarkson 1 — Could have done better with a couple of opportunities.

Norris N/A — ‘Chucked’ on for Hoever. I’m here all week.

Tell us what YOU think about this